how to write a legal studies argumentative essay

‘“The courts have expanded their powers of judicial review beyond all acceptable constitutional limits in recent decades; it is time to clip the judges’ wings.” Discuss.’

In response to such a question, it might be tempting to say in your introduction that (for example) you are going to ‘show’ how the courts’ powers of judicial review have grown, ‘consider’ why this has happened and ‘examine’ the criticisms of judicial over-reach that have resulted. These are all perfectly sensible things to do when writing an essay on this topic, but if that is all you say in your introduction, you will leave the reader wondering what you think — and what you are going to argue . In contrast, an introductory paragraph that lays the foundation for essay that properly advances a thesis will set out what that thesis is. You might, for instance, take each of the propositions set out in the question and stake out your position:

‘In this essay, I will argue that (a) while the courts’ powers of judicial review have grown in recent decades, (b) it is misguided to suggest that this has breached “all acceptable constitutional limits” and (c) that those who now advocate “clip[ping] the judges’ wings” misunderstand the role of the judiciary in a rule of law-based constitution. In other words, the courts’ judicial review powers are entirely appropriate and those who seek to limit them risk undermining the rule of law.’

An introduction of this nature would achieve two things. First, it would make clear to the reader the position you proposed to take. Second, it would immediately lend the essay a structure.

Developing your thesis

Once you have set out your thesis in the introduction, you need to develop or defend it. This will involve making a series of connected points in successive paragraphs, each of which relates to your overarching thesis. One way of thinking about this is that the individual points you make in the main body of the essay should all relate or point back in some way — and in a clear way — to the position that you staked out in the introduction.

In the example introduction above, the overarching thesis is set out in the second sentence; the individual and connecting parts of the argument are set out in propositions (a), (b) and (c) in the first sentence. One approach, therefore, would be to divide the answer, once the introduction has been written, into three parts, dealing in turn with points (a), (b) and (c). Naturally, as you work through the various parts of your argument, you will need to cite relevant evidence (cases, legislation, literature and so on) in support of your argument. You will also need to deal with matters that appear, at least at first glance, to sit in opposition to your argument (on which see further below) or which, once properly considered, require your argument to be refined.

A key point, however you proceed, is that the reader should also be clear about how each successive point relates not only to the previous point but also to the overarching argument. The reader should never be left wondering ‘Where does this fit in?’ or ‘Why am I being told this?’ A simple way of avoiding these problems is to signpost , by saying at the beginning of each section how it relates to the overall argument. The flipside of this coin is that you should avoid saying things like ‘Another point is that…’ since this gives the impression, rightly or wrongly, that the various points in your essay have been thrown together in a random order, with little thought as to how they fit together or relate to your overall argument. Even if that’s not the case, you don’t want to risk giving the reader that impression.

A one-sided approach?

The advice set about above might seem to imply that I’m suggesting you write one-sided essays — in which you set out points that support your argument while ignoring those that don’t. However, that’s not at all what I’m suggesting. In order to set out your argument in a persuasive manner, you need to deal both with relevant points that support your argument and with relevant points that appear to challenge your argument — and, in dealing with the latter points, you need to show why they do not in fact fatally undermine your argument. In other words, the approach I’m suggesting here doesn’t mean that you should adopt a blinkered approach, paying no attention to counterarguments: rather, you need to deal with them in a way that shows that, having thought about and weighed them in the balance, you are in a position to show why your argument stands in spite of them (or why your argument can be adapted in a way that accommodates such points).

All of this points towards a further matter: namely, that advancing an argument in your essay does not mean that you need to (or should) be argumentative in the sense of adopting a strident tone that brooks no debate or compromise. Rather, advancing an argument in the way I’ve suggested here means being thoughtful and persuasive : taking the reader with you on a journey that demonstrates that you have looked at the relevant material, carefully thought through the issues raised by the question, and arrived at a view that you are able to justify and defend through well-reasoned and suitably evidenced argument.

So what about your conclusion? If you’ve followed my advice above, it should more or less write itself. People often agonise over conclusions, perhaps thinking that there has to be some ‘big reveal’ at the end of their essay. But there doesn’t need to be — and indeed there shouldn’t be — any big reveal. There should be no surprises at the end precisely because you’ve set out your argument at the beginning and spent the rest of the essay carefully constructing the different strands of your argument. The conclusion is an opportunity to draw those stands together, but no-one should have to wait with bated breath for the conclusion before finally realising: ‘Ah, so that’s what they think!’ If that’s the impact of the conclusion on your reader, it means there’s something wrong with the introduction!

This post was first published on The Law Prof blog . It is re-published here with permission and thanks.

IMAGES

What Is an Argumentative Essay? Definition and Examples
Top Argumentative Essay Counterclaim Example Tips
how to write an argumentative essay college, #how #to #write #an #argumentative #essay #college
011 Argumentative Essay Sample Research ~ Museumlegs
Argumentative Essay
Argumentative Essay Help : How to Write an Argumentative Essay Worth of Teacher's Appreciation?

VIDEO

CPN 101: Steps in Writing the Argumentative Research Essay
Argumentative essay writing
ARGUMENTATIVE ESSAY
"Writing Legal Motions with Chat GPT Chat GPT will replace Paralegals Motions Demo
I have one month of college left
business comunication S2 English Studies

COMMENTS

How to Write a HSC Legal Studies Essay Scaffold in 5 Steps
How to Write a HSC Legal Studies Essay Scaffold in 5 Steps · Step 1: Analyse the question · Step 2: Come up with a thesis · Step 3: Structure your argument · Step 4
Guide to Writing an Argumentative Essay in Criminal Law
An argumentative essay aims to discuss both sides of the selected issue in order to be coherent. The writer should keep in mind that a persuasive argumentative
Writing a legal argument
To successfully write a legal case study · identify relevant legal issues · apply the law to the facts · structure your answer clearly and logically (use the model
Constructing a Legal Argument and other Assignment Tips
Assignment Tip 1: Good writing. • You cannot write an effective legal essay in poor English. Clumsy or unclear expression will spoil your arguments,.
11 Legal Studies How to write essay Pt I
A video made during class discussing how to write an essay.
Legal Studies and Law Essay Examples
Stuck on your essay? Browse essays about Legal Studies and Law and find inspiration. Learn by example and become a better writer with Kibin's suite of essay
Legal Studies
of explaining, justifying or arguing which is all done by the body of the essay. When writing your introduction, first, organize your thoughts and create an
How To Study For Legal Studies
How To Study For Legal Studies: A 7 Step Guide to Writing an A-Worthy Legal Essay · 1. Contextualise the Legal Problem · 2. Know the Legal
Law: Legal essay
Four tips on how to write a good law essay · 1. Starting your answer · 2. Planning your argument · 3. Structuring your answer · 4. Presenting your ideas.
Writing a Law essay? Remember to argue!
You should begin your essay by stating your thesis — that is, by setting out what it is that you are going to argue. This should be done in your