- RESEARCH PAPERS AND ESSAYS
- ESSAY TOPICS
- PRESIDENTS OF THE UNITED STATES
- Joseph Robinette Biden
- Donald Trump
- Barack Obama
- States Ranked by Size & Population
- States Ranked by Date
The Great Gatsby Movie And Book Comparison
The great gatsby synthesis essay.
Although the movie was beautiful on its own, it was not the same story as the original The Great Gatsby. The movie could have kept the same meaning as the novel if Luhrmann had focused less on the creative aspects and adapting the story to today’s time period. Altering these few aspects caused the true meaning to be lost in
Similarities Between The Great Gatsby Movie And Book
There were still some similarities in the film that tied back to the book. One of the main ones is when Nick walks to Gatsby’s backyard and finds him standing at the edge of his dock reaching out to what was a green light. It turns out Gatsby was reaching for Daisy since she lives just across the lake. Both the movie and the novel used the same meanings for this. Tom was also having relations with a mistress. This leads to Tom being sad when she gets run over by
Movie And Book Comparison Of The Great Gatsby
The 1925 novel, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald is considered to be an American classic and is one of the most widely-read books in modern America. There have been several film versions of the novel, most recently a 2013 version that was directed by Baz Luhrmann. Although, both the book and the film effectively portrayed the energy of the 1920s, the characters in the book and the film were not so well-aligned. In particular, the characters in the novel are complex, well-rounded people, whereas the movie tends to paint many of the key characters as simplistic archetypes.
What Is The Difference Between The Great Gatsby Book And Movie
As written in “The Great Gatsby”, the first example of similarity is that the book has the same theme to the “Roaring 20’s”. In the written book, Fitzgerald described the parties as huge and dramatic, where as in the movie, the directors did a fantastic job translating Fitzgerald’s words into a lavish visual spectacle of booze, sequins, and confetti.
Great Gatsby Movie Vs Book
The Great Gatsby is an iconic piece of American literature encompassing the 1920s era in American history. This story was written in 1923 by F. Scott Fitzgerald and was later adapted into a movie in 1949, 1973, 2000, and then once again in 2013. In the 2000 version of the movie the plot line was very similar to the book with only a few major differences and a few discreet ones as well. The movie however, also followed the book very well and even used direct quotes from the book helping you to understand the point Fitzgerald was trying to make. Markowitz the director made many good decisions in this adaptation as well as a few costly mistakes that made the importance of the book and plot line of Fitzgerald’s book. Although the book and movie
Comparing The Great Gatsby And A Streetcar Named Desire
“The Great Gatsby” and “A Streetcar Named Desire” both focus on the common theme of pursuing goals and living the American Dream. As well as leaving behind the past and “turn a new leaf”.
Death In The Great Gatsby
Literary deaths always have a meaning, and the abrupt demise of various characters in The Great Gatsby is no exception. As tensions build and secret loves are proclaimed, characters begin to meet untimely deaths. F. Scott Fitzgerald uses Gatsby and Wilson's deaths, along with Gatsby's funeral, to symbolize the death of the American dream. Both men simply want to be successful and happy, and neither of them achieve their ultimate dreams.
Hardship And Lies In The Great Gatsby
“Never make a decision when you are upset, sad, jealous or in love” said Mario Teguh. This quote states that someone should never make a big choice when they are upset or in love. If this does happen then this will lead to hardship and making bad choices. In The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald love leads to lies and hardship results in gatsby lying about who ran over Myrtle and Gatsby dieing over the revenge for Myrtle 's death.
The Great Gatsby Selfish Quotes
“As soon as I arrived I made an attempt to find my host, but the two or three people of whom I asked his whereabouts stared at me in such an amazed way, and denied so vehemently any knowledge of his movements, that I slunk off in the direction of the cocktail table – the only place in the garden where a single man could linger without looking purposeless and alone.” (Fitzgerald, 42)
Causes Of Poverty In The Great Gatsby
In the novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Jay Gatsby had one goal; Gatsby had spent his life trying to get rich and avoid poverty, which he successfully did. However, his goal was to capture the heart of one Daisy Buchanan. At one point, Daisy had been Gatsby's girlfriend. He wanted to marry her, but was sent off to war, World War I. Nick Carraway, the novel's narrator, had come to know Gatsby very well. Nick was Daisy's cousin and lived right next door to Gatsby. Throughout the novel, Nick helps Gatsby get closer to Daisy, but by the end of the book, it doesn't end well. The final line, "So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past," was iconic and appropriate for several reasons.
Aristotelian Argument: Representation Of The Great Gatsby
Luhrmann 's adaptation of Fitzgerald’s novel, The Great Gatsby, was accurate on stating the characters and their personality as well as their attitude. Though there were different actions some characters took that made them different like in the film when Gatsby got shot Daisy didn 't attend his funeral but in the novel she did. Some might say the film
The Great Gatsby Similarities Between 1970 And 2013
In both versions of the film, there were many characteristics and events that were extremely similar. In both the 1970 and 2013 Gatsby movies both movies like to party they drink and do lots of drugs they don't care about rules , they do whatever they want . Gatsby is rich and lives in west egg right across the bay from daisy , he always throws huge parties so that one day daisy well come in one day wandering and looking for gatsby he only drinks but doesn't go party with the other people or talk to them he always tends to be by himself . Men wear suits and women wear dresses there these huge houses and nice cars . Daisy husband tom buchanan is cheating on daisy with Myrtle wilson , myrtle wants to leave west egg but tom's tells
The Great Gatsby Movie Vs Movie Analysis
The Great Gatsby is a book written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. The story follows Nick, the protagonist, as he moves to New York City and starts his new life there. Throughout the book, the reader meets an abundance of horrible characters like Daisy, a self-absorbed and careless beauty, Tom, a brutal and unmoral man, and Gatsby, an ignorant and mysterious fool who wasted his life chasing a hopeless dream. Baz Luhrmann and Woody Allen are just two people of many who have recreated The Great Gatsby or dedicated a homage to it, both proving effective representations of the film.
Comparison Of Jay Gatby And Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby
4. The two stories have similar plots. They are both about men who met a woman and fell in love with her, but in one way or another, she got away from them. They spend several years of their lives gaining money and rising up in society just to get her back. In The Great Gatsby, this woman is named Daisy Buchanan, while in Winter
The Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie
In 1925, when F. Scott Fitzgerald first published the novel The Great Gatsby it sold a disappointing twenty-one thousand copies. Today more than twenty-five million copies have been sold worldwide (Lucey). Directors have take their turn making timeless novels, like The Great Gatsby, into a major motion picture. Forty-nine years after the book was published, Jack Clayton released the film “The Great Gatsby”. Now, American literature teachers are presented with the dilemma, whether or not watching the film would prove beneficial to students. In this case watching Clayton’s film proves to be beneficial to students. It stays true to Fitzgerald’s story line, the motifs are more clearly visible, and viewers are able to witness characters reactions.
More about The Great Gatsby Movie And Book Comparison
The Great Gatsby : Movie vs. Book Essay
Compare and contrast the watson go to birmingham movie.
Foremost, it is very recognizable that the overall flow of the story is same, but most of the plot events are not the same. Though, there were same events happening in both novel and the movie. For example, in both
What Are The Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book And Movie
Both the novel and movie tell the journey Mr. Gatsby went through to win Daisy over. His extravagant parties were all a part of a plan to bring Daisy back into his life for good. The story in the novel however, portrays Daisy to be selfish, and shallow. As for the movie, she presents herself as a woman of purity, and innocence but as the story goes on, she turns out
The Great Gatsby--Comparison Between 1974 Movie and the Book Essay
Most of deletions of scenes are caused by the limit of time in the movie. However, the version of 1974 Gatsby movie didn't fully succeed in manipulating the order of plots and transiting the spirituality what the author expressed, though it quoted a great deal of sentences from the book.
Daisy's Rumors In The Great Gatsby
From the beginning of the novel, Gatsby’s character is surrounded by mystery through rumors mentioned by other characters. Daisy says in Chapter I, “Gatsby? What Gatsby?” in reaction to hearing Gatsby’s name in a conversation between Nick and Jordan Baker (15). Daisy’s reaction foreshadows the illusions that surround Gatsby’s character as to which rumor they would hear about next. In Chapter II, Catherine, Myrtle’s sister, believes Gatsby to be “a nephew or a cousin of Kaiser Wilhelm’s” which is why he has so much money (37). In Chapter III, Nick attends
The Great Gatsby: Film and Novel Comparison Essay
The Great Gatsby is a novel which critically discusses the ideals of the American Dream and recapturing the past. In the film adaptation, producer Jack Clayton stays very closely to the plot and even quotes the novel verbatim but fails to capture the essence of the themes portrayed in the novel. The text did not translate well into film; some facts are distorted, the depiction of the characters are different, the general ambience of certain settings do not match, and the movie is weighted towards the beginning of the book, with half of the movie based closely on the first two chapters of the book.
Compare And Contrast The Great Gatsby Book And Movie
“What is better, the book or movie?” a commonly asked question by many individuals who are curious to know one’s opinion on a novel or film he/she is interested in. The book is usually always better than the movie because the book is more detailed, one gets to know the characters better, and it allows one to be more creative and have his/her own interpretation on what is occurring. In this case, The Great Gatsby is a remarkable 1925 novel written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, which was made into various movie adaptions in 1926, 1949, 1974, 2000 and 2013. Each version takes place in drastically different periods, so each type has its own take on the film, also depending on the director’s vision. This goes to show that the cinema has been trying periodically to recreate F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic, but the attempts of the movies have mostly failed. In particular, the 1974 film decreases its effectiveness in representing the message that Fitzgerald was attempting to demonstrate in the book, which contributes to the book being significantly better than the film for various reasons.
Similarities And Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book And Movie
There are several differences and similarities between the classic novel, The Great Gatsby, and the recent remake of the movie version. In fact, the movie version is close to identical to the book; it even uses exact quotes from the book in the movie. Overall, the most recent movie, with Leonardo DiCaprio is a great representation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s exemplary novel.
The Great Gatsby Comparison Essay
However, from the description of the novel, also from the eye contact and emotional expression of Gatsby in the movie, it can be easily found that Gatsby really loves Daisy the girl. She is the goddess in his heart all the time. It seems that there is a deep gap between Gatsby and Daisy. He cannot forget his top girl all the time and he even firmly believed that he is able to draw Daisy’s heart back as long as he can possess a huge amount of
Essay Differences Between The Movie And The Great Gatsby
In Scott Fitzgerald’s book version of The Great Gatsby, we can find many differences within the characterizations. Gatsby is portrayed differently in the book than in the movie. For example, in the book, Gatsby was frightened and aware of the fact that Daisy would never be his. In the book he was worried saying, “No telephone message arrived…” This quote shows how he seemed anxious from not hearing from Daisy. In the quote, “Gatsby
Analysis Of The Book And The Great Gatsby
Both the book and the movie initially paint Daisy Buchanan as the innocent, beautiful little fool through their associations of beauty, light and purity with the character. However, as more of Daisy’s character is revealed, her selfish, shallow and thoughtless nature is displayed through her reckless actions and she proves herself to be like all the other conceited and careless elites of East Egg. While the movie and the book both stay true to this characterization of Daisy, the movie includes a scene between Gatsby and Daisy at one of Gatsby’s party which Tom, Nick and
The Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie Essay
All too often the film industry takes a book and changes it for movie purposes. The resulting film, no matter how good or bad it may be as a stand alone, is inevitably criticized with those all too familiar words “The book was better.” However, The Great Gatsby has found itself within a group of the select few book based movies that has very few changes from the book at all. In fact, most of the lines the actors used were straight quotes from the book. A good majority of the characters, settings, words, and events in both the film and the book are identical,but not perfectly so. There are still a few things that must be changed either due to translation from page to screen or due to stylistic choice by the director.
Love and Wealth in the Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald Essay
The actor choices from the film compare to what the book envisioned, but also contrast. The character of Daisy is not similar in the film to what the book
In the book, towards the end Gatsby says “He was aware that Daisy wouldn’t be his” P.161, “No telephone message arrived” that’s when he knew Daisy wouldn’t be his. In the book it said Gatsby had died frightened but in the movie he died a “winner” some will say. In the book on Page 161 it says “He looked up at the sky through frightening leaves”
Great Gatsby: Movie vs Book
Jay Gatsby is, by far, the most complex character in both the book and the movie. He is a very mysterious person, he doesn't tell anyone anything about his past. The book shows this in more depth than the movie does, it captures his sense of mystery, and it is almost pouring out of every page. He is also a prime example of how money can't buy happiness, he had a very large mansion, he threw lavish parties, he had first editions, he had many servants, and he had the best suits, but he didn't have anyone to love him, Daisy, in the same way he loved her.
The Great Gatsby Movie And Book Comparison Essay
The tale of the Jay Gatsby is not only written by F. Scott Fitzgerald in the novel, The Great Gatsby, but also directed and produced into a movie by Baz Luhrmann. Although thematically similar and entertaining, Luhrmann’s adaptation can hardly compare to the intricate and enchanting words written by Fitzgerald. Many differences fall alongside the similarities when comparing the novel and the 2013 movie of, The Great Gatsby, including characteristics of the narrator, relationships and Gatsby’s death.
Related Topics
- F. Scott Fitzgerald
- The Great Gatsby
- Arnold Rothstein
- Fictional socialites
Comparison of The Great Gatsby novel and book
Table of Contents
The Great Gatsby is a classic American fiction novel by Francis Scott Fitzgerald, published in 1925. The plot is set in the American jazz age in New York, reflecting the class differences in different parts, primarily the East and West. The compelling story focuses on a self-reliant millionaire, Jay Gatsby, in his quest for his long-lost youth lover, Daisy Buchanan, an affluent young woman. Nick Carraway, a Yale University graduate from the Midwest, narrates the story from his point of view as he moves to New York post the First World War. This critically acclaimed novel was adapted into a 2013 movie directed by Baz Luhrmann featuring Leonardo DiCaprio as Jay Gatsby and Tobey Maguire as Nick Carraway. Luhrmann’s adaption features mostly the storyline presented in Fitzgerald’s novel. However, it is challenging to mirror a classical novel with unique dialogue and phrases into a short film without significant changes. The connection with readers created by the novel’s figurative language and sequence is quite outstanding, making it almost impossible to replicate in a two-and-a-half-hour movie. The Great Gatsby movie and book have a similar storyline and theme focus, although the movie has altered the novel’s settings, characters, and interactions.
Similarities
Despite the notable variations between The Great Gatsby movie and the novel, the two adaptions have numerous similarities in themes and character interactions. The main focus of the storyline is American society and its limitations presented in varied social classes. The ideology that some form of prosperity is achievable for any family living in America is challenged in both the book and the novel. The writer and director portray a deep contrast between the lifestyles of the West and East, as illustrated by different characters’ perceptions. Nick states, “Tom and Gatsby, Daisy and Jordan and I were all Westerners, and perhaps we possessed some deficiency in common which made us subtly unadaptable to Eastern life.” (Fitzgerald, 1925). Nick also observes the hypocrisy of American society in their desire for wealth and upward mobility. He notes, “Americans, while occasionally willing to be serfs, have always been obstinate about being peasantry” (Fitzgerald, 1925). The book and movie emphasize the hollowness of the American dream and social class differences (Egan, 2014). Gatsby’s mansion emphasizes the class differences and the wealthy upper class. Tom Buchanan’s aggressiveness and self-absorption in both the book and the movie illustrate the differences in class and power.
Differences
The main difference between The Great Gatsby movie and the book is the character of the protagonist, Nick Carraway, and how his demeanor affects other characters. The novel has quite an extensive character development that helps the readers slowly comprehend Nick Carraway’s experiences and predicament. Polan (2013) notes that, in the movie, the limited duration forces the director to alter his character to give the reader a profound insight through Nick Carraway’s narration. The movie introduces Carraway as a troubled young man struggling with alcohol addiction (Luhrmann, 2013). The demeanor seems unpleasant, but it gives him a basis to develop his character throughout the movie. As a result, Carraway is introduced as a broken figure who works with a doctor to understand and recover from his situation. Conversely, in the novel, Carraway views himself as a hopeful and positive man who sees the best in everyone. He states, “I am one of the few honest people I have ever known,” affirming honesty as his principal virtue (Fitzgerald, 1925). Through the character of Carraway in the novel, readers explore social class differences and genuine compassion as Carraway is the only character who sees beyond Gatsby’s wealth.
Similarly, there are significant differences in interactions between different characters in various settings between the novel and the movie. The director insinuates that Nick Carraway writes Gatsby’s story by hand and types the complete manuscript all by himself. However, in the novel, Fitzgerald only presents the idea that Carraway is the author but does not explore it further (Egan, 2014). While the novel shows a connection between Baker and Carraway, this questionable romance is completely erased from the movie (Luhrmann, 2013). Likewise, Carraway has a domestic worker in the novel whom he describes as valuable to his life. He remembers hiring a “Finnish woman who made [his] bed and cooked breakfast and muttered Finnish wisdom to herself over the electric stove” (Fitzgerald, 1925). However, in the movie, this character is completely cut off by the director. According to Polan (2013), Dan Cody, a rich and successful yacht owner and wealthy man, who struggles with alcohol addiction, is utterly ignorant in the book as a scheming woman, Ella Kaye, snags his inheritance. On the contrary, Dan Cody’s family inherits his wealth in the movie.
In general, The Great Gatsby movie and book have varied differences in terms of the dialogues, sequences, setting, and characters despite their similarities in theme coverage and maintaining the authenticity of the characters’ experiences. Fitzgerald’s book and Luhrmann’s adaptation of the novel both present a profound exploration of American society’s class differences, and the void of the American Dream illustrated through different characters’ predicaments. Despite the differences in how characters are presented and the dialogues in the book and movie, this story is widely anthologized today for exploring the history of American literature and society.
- Egan, K. (2014). Film Production Design: Case Study of The Great Gatsby. Elon Journal of Undergraduate Research in Communications , 5 (1).
- Fitzgerald, F. S. (1925). The Great Gatsby
- Luhrmann, B. (2013). The Great Gatsby [Film]. Hollywood; Village Roadshow Pictures A&E.
- Polan, D. (2013). The ‘Great American Novel’ as Pop-up Book: Baz Luhrmann’s The Great Gatsby. Adaptation , 6 (3), 397-399.
Short on time?
Essay Service Examples Literature The Great Gatsby
Differences Between The Great Gatsby Movie and Book
- Topics: The Great Gatsby
- Essay Type: Compare and Contrast
- Words: 1725
- This essay sample was donated by a student to help the academic community. Papers provided by EduBirdie writers usually outdo students' samples.
The Great Gatsby: Movie and Book Comparison Essay
The American Dream is the nation’s overall aspiration for America, and at America’s conception, the birth of the aspiration “rags to riches” was cultivated. America was founded by Puritans fleeing from the Western world desiring religious and governmental freedom, and wealth. This pattern that the Puritans set continued throughout America through Westward Expansion, a search for economic benefits and assets, which was exemplified by historical occurrences like The Gold Rush of 1848. The Great Gatsby takes place in 1922, just seven years before the detrimental economic recession of the Great Depression. The Great Gatsby portrays main themes like the American Dream, roles of femininity, masculinity, vice, materialism, class, and sub-themes like old money versus new money. However, The Great Gatsby provides symbolism about the American Dream: It shows the greed of the corrupt. When comparing the novel The Great Gatsby by Scott F. Fitzgerald to that of the 2013 film directed by Baz Luhrmann, the movie is no longer about the literary eloquence that a book may focus on, but about the entertainment aspect, about drawing the eyes of the viewers into the production. Although both interpretations of The Great Gatsby present similar ideals, the portrayal of the American Dream in the movie in comparison to the film has become overdramatized as demonstrated by its treatment of status, wealth, and romance.
Historically, New York, let alone the United States, is highly segregated by socioeconomic status. However, in The Great Gatsby, one of the things that all the classes share is the American Dream to achieve wealth. Though, this achievement was still divided by class because within the wealthy, there was still a social divide between those who were born into it and those of the “rags to riches” prototype. However, Luhrmann’s portrayal of status in the movie has been overdramatized to display the divisions between class and status further. For example, in the movie, during the argument between Tom and Gatsby, Tom taunts Gatsby’s new money status by saying, “Oh no, no, we’re different. I am, they are, she is, we’re all different from you. We were born different, it’s in our blood, and nothing you do, or say, or steal or dream up, can ever change that.” (Luhrmann, 2013.) This statement displays the grudge and superiority complex that Tom has for those of East Egg status which includes Gatsby, making Gatsby feel inferior, and retaliates into a rageful fit. While East and West Egg continues their rivalries, they stay blissfully unaware that their life in luxury is creating a disproportionate wealth gap for those of the lowest status, those in the Valley of Ashes. The Valley of Ashes in the book is described as, “[a] desolate area of land.” (Fitzgerald, pg. 23.) The movie and Luhrmann’s work stay true to the visualization that the Valley of Ashes was area where “ashes grow like wheat into ridges and hills and grotesque gardens where ashes take the forms of houses and chimneys and rising smoke and finally, with a transcendent effort, of men who move dimly and already crumbling through the powdery air.” (Fitzgerald, pg. 23.) Though unlike the book, the movie puts less emphasis on the Valley of Ashes being a desolate, barren wasteland with scattered businesses but over-dramatizes it as an area with an abundance of urbanization filled with excessive amounts of ash, grime and poverty, but still yet a city that has become torn apart and become a hellscape those who inhabit it.
- Proper editing and formatting
- Free revision, title page, and bibliography
- Flexible prices and money-back guarantee
As explained in the movie by Nick Carraway, in the time of 1922 “stocks hit record peaks, and Wall Street boomed, in a steady golden roar. The parties were bigger, the shows were broader, the buildings were higher, the morals were looser, and the ban on alcohol had backfired making the liquor cheaper.” (Luhrmann, 2013.) With the stock market skyrocketing, it made the American Dream of wealth more accessible to those who could obtain it more effortless than ever. In the book, the theme of wealth is shown consistently through its portrayal and vast differences in status. However, what differs from the book to the film is that the film’s sensationalized focal points seem to revolve around the grand and extravagant parties. Although Luhrmann’s interpretation still encapsulates the ideas of Fitzgerald’s visions, it also adds flairs of modernism, by including music scores of rap from artists like Kanye West and Jay-Z, instead of the expected 1920s themed jazz. The flashy party lacks the scenes that in the book provide a sense of calamity even from within the party, and provide depth on the characters such as the twin girls in the yellow dresses, or the elaborate description of the crying woman, or the car accident. These scenes are now quick jump-cuts, making the activities at the party overstimulating, overwhelming, and generates a head-spinning, alcohol-induced effect to the viewer, as alcohol is a well-known theme to the Roaring Twenties. As the film progresses towards the end, it shows Gatsby’s shocking death was bombarded with the publication, but amongst that publication, there were only a small number of people in both the book and the movie who went to his funeral or even cared. In the book, Wolfsheim sent his regards, and Gatsby’s father, Henry, sent a telegram to postpone the funeral until he arrived in New York, and when he arrived, marveled at his son’s legacy and was proud of him. While in the movie, the only one who came to the funeral aside from paparazzi was Nick Carraway himself. The overdramatization in the lack of people who came to Gatsby’s funeral shows how the journey of the American Dream of wealth is isolating, which Gatsby even admits in the movie, saying “you know, I thought for a while I had a lot of things. But the truth is I’m empty.” (Luhrmann, 2013) Gatsby was always surrounded by people who either despised or idolized his status but were never indeed his friends, aside from Nick Carraway. Daisy does not show up to his funeral or send her regards, because she has once again chosen the security of wealth with Tom over true love. The American Dream was full of greed because nothing was ever sustainable or fulfilling.
In The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby battles an equilibrium: the American Dream of wealth, and the American Dream of true love. Gatsby realizes he must achieve the American Dream of wealth first before he even attempts to achieve the American Dream of true love and to get Daisy back. Romanticism is a prevalent theme in both the movie and the film, but Luhrmann uses romanticism to his advantage, to over-dramatize the innocence and purity of true love. In the movie, when Nick first walks into the Buchanan’s home to visit Daisy, the lens flares as the doors swing open to reveal a white room brightly lit by sunlight, as flowy sheer white curtains float momentarily in the air, while a crystal chandelier hangs overhead, as bubbly laughter fills the room. Soon, Daisy’s dainty and feminine hand rises over the cream sofa, and she calls for Nick. These motifs that Luhrmann strategically uses are no coincidence, as it displays goodness of life, femininity, hope, purity, naiveté, and innocence that Daisy resembles. Daisy resembles these characteristics because her corruption is never her decision, but is always forced upon her, as in example stated before by her forced to choose financial security over true love and happiness by external factors, either her parents or her husband, Tom Buchanan. These attributes of Daisy’s add to the complexity of Gatsby and Daisy’s relationship, which take center stage as much of the plot in both the film and the novel. However, one character plot that the movie lacked is the romantic relationship between Nick Carraway and famous golfer, Jordan Baker. Although Nick allegedly has another girl in waiting for him back home in the Midwest, he continues with this relationship with Jordan. At one point in the book, Nick Carraway notes, “[Jordan’s] grey, sun-strained eyes stared straight ahead, but she had deliberately shifted our relations, and for a moment I thought I loved her.” (Fitzgerald, pg. 58.) Nick insights on the intense and sentimental relationship that was developing between him and Jordan, and despite this character development, Luhrmann decided to cut it entirely from the movie, shifting the focus to the dramatic synopsis of the love triangle between Jay Gatsby, and Daisy and Tom Buchanan, drawing more attention and sensationalizing romantic aspect in the film.
When comparing the literature of Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby to Luhrmann’s work on the motion picture of The Great Gatsby, we see universal ideals through the commonalities of the American Dream for the Eastern United States during the Roaring Twenties. However, the portrayal of the American Dream in the movie in comparison to the film has become overdramatized by Luhrmann’s treatment of status, wealth, and romance in order to sensationalize the novel. We continue to see tactics like Luhrmann’s used to modernize classic literature into Hollywood produced movies. The ending of The Great Gatsby differs as well. In the novel, Nick goes home to the Midwest, the East now filled with toxicity. In the movie, Nick seeks psychiatric help and is being treated by a psychologist as a, “morbidly alcoholic, insomniac, fits of anger, anxiety, depression” (Luhrmann, 2013.) What stays the same is the lesson learned by Nick, is that time is ever-fleeting. Nick voices this saying, “[Gatsby] had come such a long way, and his dream must have seemed so close that he could hardly fail to grasp it. He did not know that it was already behind him. Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year, recedes before us. It eluded us then, but that’s no matter. tomorrow we will run faster, Stretch out our arms farther, and one fine morning, So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly, into the past.” (Luhrmann, 2013.) In the end, Gatsby’s dream was not achieved, and Nick realized the corruption of the American Dream surrounding him, but the only thing that continued to move on was hope and time, so as life does, it beats on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly, into the past.
Works Cited:
- Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. Penguin Books, 2018.
- Luhrmann, Baz, director. The Great Gatsby. Village Roadshow Pictures, Bazmark Productions, A&E Productions, Red Wagon Entertainment, 2013
Our writers will provide you with an essay sample written from scratch: any topic, any deadline, any instructions.
Cite this Page
Get your paper done in as fast as 3 hours, 24/7.
Related essay Topics
Popular Categories
Most Popular Essays
- The Great Gatsby
- The Great Gatsby Symbolism
Chapter 1: Setting “I graduated from New Haven in 1915, just a quarter of a century after my father, and a little later I participated in that delayed Teutonic migration known as the Great War. I enjoyed the counter-raid so thoroughly that I came back restless. Instead of being the warm center of the world the middle-west now seemed like the ragged edge of the universe—so I decided to go east and learn the bond business. Everybody I knew was...
This essay focuses on the novel The Great Gatsby and how the American Dream is portrayed in Nick Carraway and Jay Gatsby through the three aspects: beliefs from the “Lost Generation”, social-economic classes, and values towards romantic relationships. Through contrasting the American Dream of the two characters, how Fitzgerald contrives the outlook of the American dream in the specific cultural context displays. It establishes the American Dream’s transformation and influence throughout 1930s American history. Therefore it displays its significance as...
- What It Means to Be an American
In modern society, being an American means to be free and loyal. Being free means to live in the country without prejudices and to have the ability to fairly attain your dreams. On the other hand, “fake it till you make it” is a phrase adopted by Americans, which simply means to imitate certain qualities one wishes to have until one does obtain those qualities. With this phrase in mind, people create a mirage of their idealized selves in order...
- Death of a Salesman
Death of a Salesman, written by Arthur Miller in 1949, is a novel that focuses on the family life and how they have been affected by the society as far as destiny of an individual is in this case concerned. On the other hand Great Gatsby is the name of the novel that was authored by Fitzgerald during the year 1925 and it focuses greatly on the western society that was in this case capitalistic and the dominant one concerning...
- American Dream
The contrast between the new rich and the old rich is a prominent theme in the novel and is reinforced by certain techniques throughout the novel. Fitzgerald uses characterization to portray the contrast between the two cultures on Long Island. The ambitious and bombastic new rich of West Egg and the careless, shallow and aristocratic old rich of East Egg. Characterization is used to reinforce this theme. Fitzgerald uses the old rich as antagonists for the narrative. Tom, an aristocrat...
Effective texts contain recognisable narrative tropes that facilitate new understandings of our world and ourselves. This is evident in William Shakespeare’s play, Othello, and F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel, The Great Gatsby which both portray new understandings of the tragic hero narrative trope. A tragic hero is a character who begins of a noble status or of great virtue. Though this character is pre-eminently great, he or she is not perfect and has a significant character flaw or hamartia. This tragic...
The novel, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is centred around Jay Gatsby and his pursuit to obtain his long-lived goal that is Daisy Buchannan. It follows the path of his life, showing the sheer dedication and effort he applies to his plan towards his final purpose. Written in the 1920s, The Great Gatsby mirrors it’s society and exposes popular ideals of the time. The novel challenges the central beliefs of the American Dream, hedonism and classism in the...
F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby published in 1925 explores the setting of the 1920’s to comment and reflect upon his context. He does this by critiquing his era through the ideas of unfulfillment and superficial values caused by the American dream. He reviews the Jazz Age through his portrayal of celebrations after World War I, the industrial developments and corruption. He also comments on changes in social and moral values due to world war one disillusionment. Through these...
- Scott Fitzgerald
Modern American youth are seemingly often delusional about a life filled with promise and self-satisfaction to of which they see suitable for themselves; however, this mere illusion has the capacity to tempt people to advocate towards their aspirations in life and lead them to what is believed to be the American Dream. The American Dream in the modern American youth is generally portrayed as having luxuries such as a high ranked social status, a higher level of education, having an...
- Get original paper written according to your instructions
- Save time for what matters most
Fair Use Policy
EduBirdie considers academic integrity to be the essential part of the learning process and does not support any violation of the academic standards. Should you have any questions regarding our Fair Use Policy or become aware of any violations, please do not hesitate to contact us via [email protected]
We are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours.
Stage and Cinema
Arts Reviews
Extras/Book/Film: EXAMINING THE GREAT GATSBY: MOVIE VS. BOOK
by Aveline MacQuoid on November 24, 2022
in Books , Extras , Film
EXAMINING THE GREAT GATSBY: MOVIE VS. BOOK
The Great Gatsby is a novel that has been made into two movies; one in 1926 and another in 2013. Both movies are based on the book written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. While the book is considered to be a classic, the movies have received mixed reviews.
Online reference on The Great Gatsby
When it comes to writing college essays on The Great Gatsby, there are several topics to consider. You could discuss the role of money in the novel or the way that Fitzgerald uses symbols to create meaning. Alternatively, you could analyze one of the book’s main characters, such as Gatsby or Daisy, or explore the role of gender in the novel.
Fitzgerald’s writing style helps to bring the era to life for modern readers. In addition, the novel’s themes of love, betrayal, and greed continue to resonate with readers today. As a result, it is no wonder that so many college students choose to write essays on The Great Gatsby.
There are different approaches that students can take while writing essays on this great story. No matter what approach you take, it offers a wealth of material for thoughtful essays. There are some considerable differences between the movies, which can confuse a student who is writing a research paper on this great story. But to make sense of it all, free essay examples and a lot of essays on “The Great Gatsby” for students on GradesFixer are available for references. It improves writing and makes students more confident when submitting their papers.
The storyline
It narrates the story of a rich man by the name of Jay who is obsessed with his married lady love, Daisy Buchanan, with whom he has an affair. But they are unable to be united due to their social classes. The story tragically ends with his death and the lady driving off with her husband.
Scott Fitzgerald wrote the novel The Great Gatsby and published the book in the year 1925 against the roaring twenties backdrop. It is praised for its social commentary on the Jazz Age, which is filled with ambition and hope for the great American dream. It remains the most widely-read and popular book of the century.
The Great Gatsby is considered a great novel in America and has been adapted into a couple of films. In 1974, it was adapted into a movie of the same name starring Mia Farrow and Robert Redford. The recent movie adaptation release was in 2013, starring Leonardo DiCaprio. It received praise for its soundtrack and visuals.
The Great Gatsby differences between the movie and book
One of the most obvious differences is that the book is told from the perspective of Nick Carraway, while the movie focuses on Gatsby himself. As a result, the book provides a more nuanced portrait of Gatsby, delving into his past and motivations for throwing lavish parties to win over Daisy Buchanan.
The movie paints Gatsby as a somewhat one-dimensional figure, emphasizing his wealth without fully exploring his character. Critics of The Great Gatsby book point out another difference between the two versions. And that is that the book contains a much more detailed account of Gatsby’s relationship with Daisy, while the movie glosses over this part of the story.
The Great Gatsby movies comparison
While The Great Gatsby scenes in the movie were well-received, it was not without their critics. Some viewers, when comparing The Great Gatsby movie vs book, felt that it strayed too far from the original novel, while others complained that it was simply too long.
However, there are also many similarities between the book and the movie. Both tell the story of Jay Gatsby, a wealthy man who is obsessed with a former flame. Both versions make use of flashbacks to fill in Gatsby’s backstory, and both include a tragic ending. And there is no denying that both versions capture the essence of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic novel.
Should students watch the movie?
There are many reasons why students should watch the movie. First, it can help them to better understand the book. The film provides a visual representation of the characters and settings, which can be helpful for students who are struggling to picture them in their minds. Additionally, the film can give students a deeper understanding of the plot and themes.
The Great Gatsby is simply a great movie. It is well-acted and well-crafted, and it provides an enjoyable experience for viewers of all ages. For all these reasons, students should watch The Great Gatsby movie.
Conclusion
The Great Gatsby is a great read of all time that captures the imagination of the reader and resonates at every level. If you’re looking for a more traditional take on the story, then go with the 1974 film. However, if you’re open to seeing The Great Gatsby in a new light, then check out the 2013 adaptation.
Share this post:
Comments on this entry are closed.
- Theater-Chicago
- Theater-Las Vegas
- Theater-Los Angeles
- Theater-New York
- Theater-Regional
- Theater-San Francisco / Bay Area
- Privacy Statement
Search reviews by title or key words.
Please help keep stage and cinema going, while we assert that it’s time to rethink the existence of facebook, here’s our page.
Essay on The Great Gatsby: Film and Novel Comparison
The Great Gatsby: Film and Novel Comparison The Great Gatsby is a novel which critically discusses the ideals of the American Dream and recapturing the past. In the film adaptation, producer Jack Clayton stays very closely to the plot and even quotes the novel verbatim but fails to capture the essence of the themes portrayed in the novel. The text did not translate well into film; some facts are distorted, the depiction of the characters are different, the general ambience of certain settings do not match, and the movie is weighted towards the beginning of the book, with half of the movie based closely on the first two chapters of the book. Gatsby Gatsby’s character in the novel is very distinct from his portrayal in the film. In the …show more content… Aside from the above, the other differences I observed are not very significant as they do not alter Fitzgerald’s meaning for the novel. The addition or omission of various insignificant scenes could effectively direct the audience’s attention to more pivotal scenes. • Neither the man with whom Nick had planned to share his house with nor their maid were ever introduced in the movie. • In the novel, Gatsby and Nick’s first encounter took place at the party. Nick was very relaxed and spoke casually with Gatsby because he was unaware of his identity. In the novel, however, their first acquaintance took place at Gatsby’s office. Nick knew Gatsby wanted to speak to him because his butler had informed Nick of this prior to their conversation, which very formal as a result. • Gatsby is never shown requesting Jordan to ask Nick to arrange a meeting between Daisy and Gatsby. • In the novel, Gatsby grows impatient while waiting for Daisy to arrive for their meeting and takes a walk around the house. In the film, Gatsby does not talk a walk outside the house. • During Gatsby and Daisy’s reunion, they claim they have met for 8 years. In the novel, they had been acquainted for only 5 years. • After Daisy and Gatsby are reunited, they dance in Gatsby’s mansion. In the film, they dance with only the light from a candle. In the book, they dance with only the light gleaming from the hallway. • At Gatsby’s party, a dog prances on a table Show More
Related Documents: Essay on The Great Gatsby: Film and Novel Comparison
Essay The Great Gatsby
Brenda Yan, Nicole Miller, Jose Marquez, Lilli Spahn Lee Junior English Day 2 Period 1 2015 April 6 Gatsby, not so Great Many readers desire for their favorite books to become movies, although they should be careful what they wish for. The Great Gatsby (2013) is no doubt a fantastic film. However, it does not completely capture the essence of the original novel. Director Baz Luhrmann was not effective in recreating the feel and imagery of the iconic historical fiction written by F…
Words 743 - Pages 3
The Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie Essay
drastically. The film adaptation of the novel The Great Gatsby reshapes the significance of the moments right before Gatsby’s death, the omittance of Gatsby’s father from the funeral, and the future of Nick Carraway. These contrasts create differing viewpoints of the lives of Gatsby and Nick and of the personalities of the two characters themselves. First of all, the film adaptation includes a scene at the end that is not originally part of the written novel. The scene is of Gatsby in his pool when…
Words 704 - Pages 3
The Great Gatsby Classic Essay
2/17/14 “Gatsby” Classic Essay Position: “The Great Gatsby” is a classic because of its still relatable content, standing the test of time, and its unceasing popularity with readers even today. Since its debut in 1925, F. Scott Fitzgerald’s groundbreaking novel about the rigidness of time, society’s blindness to reality, and the downright satirical nature of a dream, has captivated audiences worldwide, as it has been translated into 42 languages such as “El Gran Gatsby” in Spanish and “Gatsby le Magnifique”…
Words 1131 - Pages 5
Gatsby: F. Scott Fitzgerald and Gatsby Essay
1A: 5:35 MW 25 March 2014 The Great Gatsby The plot and the setting of both the book and movie are very similar. The movie followed the plot of book very closely and portrayed the setting of the book very well. Almost all of the dialogue was borrowed and spoken directly as it was in the book. "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a novel that talks about Jay Gatsby's love for Daisy Buchanan. It talks about the American Dream and everything Gatsby does to try to win Daisy over. I really…
Words 1151 - Pages 5
Similarities Between F Scott Fitzgerald And The Great Gatsby
Behind the Scenes of F. Scott Fitzgerald and the Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby was written by American author F. Scott Fitzgerald is an all time favorite and one of the most overrated books in the U.S. This masterpiece was written in the 1920’s, an era where the country seemed almost perfect. The economy was at its peak, money was spent like crazy, alcohol was prohibited making it more desirable, expensive, and making illegal distributors filthy rich. The way people drove their lives in this era…
Words 1213 - Pages 5
The Great Gatsby: Differences Between Book And Movie
Show More There are a good amount of differences between the Great Gatsby movie and the book, yet most of them are the same. The differences and similarities are definitely noticeable. The setting of the novel is different from the film. Tom is just one of the five characters that were portrayed very much like the novel. The apartment party had the same idea and intentions just was tweaked a little in the film. The setting between the novel and the film of The Great Gatsby have their differences and similarities. Both the novel and the film are in Gatsby’s house half of the time because of the parties that take place there. Nick’s house makes a few appearances considering he lives next to Gatsby and Daisy and Gatsby have tea there. Similar places like East egg, West egg, and Valley of Ashes have been mentioned. The book Portrays Tom as a jerk. He makes several racist and sexist remarks. It is easy to dislike …show more content… Nick joins them, and the film shows Nick sitting in the apartment’s living room while Tom and Myrtle have loud sex in the bedroom. Fitzgerald doesn’t say that but something like that is implied. The film also shows Myrtle’s sister Catherine giving Nick a pill that she says she got from a doctor in Queens; that’s not in the novel at all. In the movie Nick wakes up at home, partially dressed, unsure how he got there, while the novel’s narrator wakes up in an apartment downstairs from Tom and Myrtle’s apartment, owned by one of their friends. Then he goes to the train station to take the train home. There are a good amount of differences between the Great Gatsby movie and the book, yet most of them are the same. The setting of the novel is different from the film. Tom is just one of the five characters that were portrayed very much like the novel. The apartment party had the same idea and intentions just was tweaked a little in the film. The differences and similarities are definitely
Related Documents
So b movie vs book essay.
The So B. It book and movie are similar in many ways, but it is also different in ways too. The book and the movie of So B. It are the same in many ways. In the book and movie, Heidi still meets up with Roy and Ruby and spends time at their house while she is in Liberty.…
Compare And Contrast Of Mice And Men Book And Movie
Of mice and Men Novel vs. Movie Have you ever watched a movie of a written book? There are many books that have movies to come with them. However, the movies usually has some difference compared to the book, but the concept and the majority are all the same. Of mice and men is one of those books. The novel and the movie have many similar features.…
Book Vs Movie Essay
Though most of differences are opinionated, some are factual such as the length of the story, the visual of the movie against the imaginative aspect of books, and the perspective of both. Among their many differences, they have a small handful of similarities. They both tell the same story or at least a story that is similar. Also they follow a similar plot and have identical or resembling characters. The first major…
Differences Between The Wizard Of Oz Movie And Book
The plots of the book and the movie are quite similar, except for some rather minor details. One of the most notable and obvious differences between the book and movie are Dorothy’s shoes. In the movie, Dorothy’s slippers are ruby red and in the movie they are silver. There are different theories going around about the shoes color change between the movie and book.…
The Pride And Prejudice Movie And Book Comparison
The Novel was published in the 18th century by Jane Austen, whereas the movie was realeased in 2005 by Joe Wright based on the novel by Jane Austen. It was a good adaptation of the novel and almost everything was the same. The Pride and Prejudice movie may not be as descriptive as the novel, but still shows major themes that should be represented from Jane Austen 's time. There are many differences between the novel and movie. The difference between novel and their movies is that there is a lot lost in translations.…
The Antagonist In The Landlady
The driver asked the boy if he wanted to use the phone in a last time kind of way. After the gas station, the boy realized that he was going to be the eighth kill. In the short story the Landlady, Billy Weaver went to a bed and breakfast. There the landlady was very suspicions of something. After Billy was settled in his room he went down stairs to sign the book and sip his tea.…
The Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie Essay
Period 4 English 3 CP Mrs. Iannuzzi The Great Gatsby Movie Review After reading the novel, “The Great Gatsby” by F. Scott Fitzgerald, and now watching the movie, it is apparent that there were several differences made from the book to the movie that are both good and bad. Although there were minor things changed from the book to the movie, the overall theme and plot remains the same. The actors chosen for this movie portrayed the characters of the book very well, and the movie gives an accurate portrayal of the novel, but there was some changes and scenes that were blown out of proportion, making the movie too extravagant and distasteful. One major change from the novel to the movie was the past of the character of Nick Carraway. In the book, Nick is telling his story of Gatsby and Daisy as a…
1984 Movie Vs Book Analysis
Just like Harry Potter, The Hunger Games and even The Great Gatsby, 1984 falls into the category of the book being better than the movie in my perspective. When you compare the book, 1984, to the movie, you can easily distinguish the differences. Although there were a few highlights in the movie, it was not my “cup of tea”. In my opinion, if I haven’t read the book before, I wouldn’t understand what the story would be about and be downright puzzled. Therefore the book, 1984, was decently written, but the movie wasn’t well interpreted.…
Pride And Prejudice Book Vs Movie Analysis
The movie is a very fine and delicate narration of the book, although it didn’t keep close to the movie. Anyway, it is up to person to decide what is better, tastes differ and one opinion will no necessarily match with another. I do recommend those who haven’t read or watched Pride and Prejudice either to read or to watch it or…
The Godfather Character Analysis
The transition of The Godfather was no different. Though the film was superb for its time, there was quite a lot of the novel left out of it. I personally consider some of that to be a good thing; especially in concern of some of the extra characters and subplots. One of those characters is Johnny Fontane. He makes his appearance in the film, but instead of playing the major role that he had in the novel, he is now more of an ornamental character.…
Related Topics
- Black people
- Nazi Germany
- Nathaniel Hawthorne
- The Scarlet Letter
- Hester Prynne
Ready To Get Started?
- Create Flashcards
- Mobile apps
- Accessibility
- Cookie Settings
Compare And Contrast The Great Gatsby Book And Movie
Baz Luhrmann’s movies are known for their unorthodox visuals and creatively inserted music into the scene. Recently, he received some negative responses from his movie adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby. His movie adaptation was considered unfaithful to the original text or story, despite using most of the same text and action. Luhrmann’s movie adaptation modified the original text in a distinct way, especially through the hyperbolic representation of Jay Gatsby ’s parties and the choice of modern soundtrack. The movie didn’t quite touched the viewers as well as the original novel did, it only skimmed through the scenes and focused more on the “party” section that was mentioned in the novel. The Great Gatsby movie adaptation …show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how tom throws a private party for his mistress, myrtle wilson, while nick, who involuntarily joined, is shown sitting in the apartment's living room.
- Analyzes how cinematography plays an important role in the movie industry. luhrmann's movie adaptation is visually stunning, but it seems abstract.
- Analyzes how baz luhrmann's movie adaptation of the great gatsby was considered unfaithful to the original text.
- Opines that luhrmann's soundtrack choices are eccentric and unfaithful to the era of the story. fitzgerald achieved a better job of connecting with the audience with pen and paper back in the 1920s.
- Concludes that baz luhrmann's movie adaptation of the great gatsby will nevermore be as satisfying as f. scott fitzgerald original version.
Although some of the plots in the novel were used in the movie adaptation, but there were a lot that was altered as well. The Great Gatsby story starts off with the narrator, Nick Carraway, who moved from the Midwest to New York to learn about the bond business. He lives on the island of West Egg, which across from East Egg, where his cousin Daisy and her husband, Tom Buchanan live. Nick is neighbours with a mysterious man named Jay Gatsby, who is the main protagonist of the novel and the movie. Gatsby is predominantly known for throwing extravagant parties every weekend at his mansion in West Egg. He is suspected to be a bootlegger and does illegal activities as how he earns money. The story continues as Gatsby goes to extreme measures to try and …show more content…
Scott Fitzgerald original version of the novel. The movie adaptation lacked the emotional connection with the viewers. Baz Luhrmann focused more on creating a visual excitement and very little else. The texts in Fitzgerald’s novel jumps out to readers as they are reading, the novel is passionate, meaningful and magnificently written. While Luhrmann’s movie adaptation just jumps out to the viewers with 3 dimensional effects. It was a valiant effort by Baz Luhrmann, but the use of 3-D effect in this movie was unnecessary, the extravagant party scenes came out repetitive and shallow. The peculiar and atypical rhetorical choices in this movie adaptation were essentially used just because Luhrmann is drawn to the idea of “modernizing” the novel, to interpret ideas and theme to younger audiences in an applicable settings, while also incorporating passage from an older era. Luhrmann had failed to appeal
- Analyzes how the novel version of the great gatsby challenges the reader's creativity and imagination to understand the words that describe the character accurately.
- Opines that fitzgerald's the great gatsby is still the best representation of the romantic hero and his american dream, despite interpreters like david merrick in his film version to 'usurp' it.
- Analyzes how nick carraway's narration conveys the story without any outside influence from the other characters in the plot. nick is a very moralistic man and his morals and values are positively genuine.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald's novel portrays daisy as a superficial, shallow, and snobbish individual who wants to protect her daughter pammy from any other heartache.
- Analyzes how symbolism is effective in the novel the great gatsby. the novel is a superior piece of art, enabling the reader to experience it on an intellectual basis rather than just an entertainment.
- Analyzes how both the novel and the movie version of the great gatsby are wonderful interpretations of a well-written story line from the 1920's.
- Opines that the 1974 hollywood film version of the great gatsby fails to depict the complex elegance and superficiality of the twenties.
- Analyzes how the owl-eyed man, an important symbol in the novel, is left out of the movie.
- Analyzes how the car accident outside of gatsby's house does not occur in the movie. the owl-eyed man crashes his car, but he reveals that someone else was driving.
- Analyzes how the owl-eyed man is one of the only people who attended gatsby’s funeral out of a handful of servants, nick, and the postman in the novel.
- Analyzes how the film fails to depict the essence of the great gatsby. jack clayton's decisions on the positioning of cameras, facial expressions of cast members, and movement of the actors wrongfully depicts fitzgerald’s story.
- Analyzes how gatsby's speech in the novel is fake, since he is portraying a false identity to others, but the context and background of why is missing from the movie.
- Analyzes how myrtle punching and breaking her bedroom window were over-dramatic and unnecessary additions to the film. gatsby and daisy's interactions were awkward beyond their initial meeting.
- Analyzes how the film's positive attributes were overshadowed by its negative characteristics.
- Opines that clayton's poor choices as a director caused the film to suffer. the awkwardness of characters, unnecessary additions, and failure to capture the essence of the novel created an unenjoyable and disappointing reaction for fans of the great gatsby.
- Opines that the book, the great gatsby by f. scott fitzgerald, is superior to the movie adaptation because many scenes were altered and visual aids were not as relevant.
- Analyzes how gatsby's extravagant parties did not depict the vision that must have wanted the reader to see. the movie didn't even bother to show the climax of the theme of friendship in the book.
- Analyzes how many characters in the book were not portrayed as they should have been in movie. nick was addressed as an alcoholic, while jordan was plain and boring.
- Analyzes how gatsby's watch, dog collar, and green light in the movie didn't represent the story plot or book. the movie did a lousy job when it came to symbols and received mixed reviews.
- Analyzes how the book trumps the movie and everyone's heart is disappointed by the horrors and mistakes of cinema. gatsby once again has an unintended funeral.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald's novel the great gatsby is centered on memory and going back in time.
- Analyzes how the great gatsby gives each generation a thorough reflection of what life/culture was like during that period.
- Analyzes how the great gatsby leaves a lasting image of the cast and plot, and references the issues of monetary values and spiritual well-being.
- Analyzes how the green light symbolizes ambition, revival, and commitment in gatsby's life.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald's the great gatsby tells the tragic story of two star-crossed lovers. the roaring twenties were a time of promiscuity, new money, and illegal alcohol.
- Analyzes how gatsby acquires all of his wealth so that in his mind he will be good enough for daisy, leading one to believe that money is as important to her as other aspects of her partners.
- Analyzes how the great gatsby shows how the rich can shirk their own responsibilities and do unethical things in the interest of self-preservation.
- Analyzes how the 1920s were a period of unprecedented prosperity and wealth, and the american dream. the circumstances surrounding gatsby's wealth highlight fitzgerald’s skepticism.
- Analyzes how gatsby was good to people of all classes and backgrounds. the rich were more frequently around the poor than they are today.
- Analyzes how donating to charitable causes is a widespread among the world's wealthy people. in the great gatsby, wealth is wasted on lavish parties for people who are indifferent about him.
- Analyzes how morality isn't directly discussed in the great gatsby, but is often alluded to ironically. tom buchanan uses this as a social commentary on the subject of moral decay in america.
- Explains that the great gatsby was a tool used by fitzgerald to identify some of the flaws that plagued society in 1920s america.
- Explains that the american dream is a book by f. scott fitzgerald, published by charles scribner's sons.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald's the great gatsby conveys a position on the united states in the 1920s using various techniques embedded throughout the novel.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald employs imagery to help the reader conceptualize his ultimate goal of the bright and extremely "alive" feeling within the room.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald conveys a heightened sense of realism, to the point of being surrealistic. nick reveals the vagueness about gatsby in an offhand way, as if to tell the reader that this was normal.
- Analyzes how fitzgerald delineates the lawlessness of the 1920's in a multitude of ways.
- Analyzes how f. scott fitzgerald illustrates with artful tact his view of the united states in the 1920's.
- Compares f. scott fitzgerald's novel the great gatsby and nick cassavetes' film the notebook to illustrate the idea that first love never dies.
- Analyzes how both the great gatsby and the notebook deal with the idea of the lower class being unable to have a relationship with more wealthy, higher class.
- Analyzes how noah calhoun, the main character, falls in love with a woman more wealthy than he is, allie hamilton, and her parents don't want them to be together.
- Analyzes how the great gatsby and the notebook present the couples reconnecting with one another after many years past.
- Analyzes how noah sends allie a letter, hoping she would forgive him. the two were separated for years, but noah was still in love with her.
- Analyzes how daisy and allie are left with a complication in their relationship. while gatsby was gone, daisy could not keep waiting for him and wondered about him.
- Analyzes how noah and allie spent time together after being apart for so long, feeling as if they never left each other.
- Compares the great gatsby written by f. scott fitzgerald and the notebook directed by nick cassavetes, presenting the idea that first love is the strongest and can never die.
- Analyzes how "the great gatsby" is a novel written by f. scott fitzgerald and set in new york city during the 1920s.
- Analyzes how the novel incorporates a different view of the american dream. gatsby's death is an example of this.
- Analyzes how symbolism in "the great gatsby" represents ideals that we would and would not think of right away.
- Explains that the eyes are a strong symbol in the novel because they represent people like daisy, tom, myrtle etc, who do things that are wrong but don't want to be caught at that certain time.
- Opines that jay gatsby is a very deceptive character in the novel. he is relatable to teenagers because of his goal of getting daisy.
- Opines that gatsby's death is the most powerful scene in the novel. his obsession over the past of daisy and getting her back is what causes his death.
- Concludes that "the great gatsby" is phenomenal because of the use of simple but powerful symbols, fitzgerald's words and in general the story.
- Analyzes how the great gatsby is a great novel set in new york city, in the summer of 1922.
- Analyzes how the novel has a dramatic ending with one thing happening after the other. tom and gatsby have verbal altercation due to james messing around with his wife. daisy runs over her husband’s mistress.
- Opines that the theme of the great gatsby is mankind's imperfection.
- Analyzes how the book's main theme is about mankind imperfections because all the characters in the story have baggage. tom cheating on his wife with myrtle, gatsby illegal earning of his fortune because he was most likely a bootlegger of alcohol.
- Analyzes the sub-theme of mankind's imperfections that leaves them curious about how a married man or women can have an affair but still claim to love their spouse.
- Analyzes how tom makes no effort to hide his affair, as he takes nick who is daisy cousin to meet his mistress and ends the night with a party in tom and myrtle's apartment.
- Narrates how daisy was upset about her husband's affair with myrtle and started messing around with her ex-lover james gatz after nick arranged for them to meet again.
- Analyzes how tom began to get suspicious of his wife and james, which to me is ignorant considering he hasn't been faithful in the relationship.
- Explains that daisy chose tom over daisy because james loves her more, but she chose gatsby. divorce was looked down upon in the 1920s.
- Opines that daisy loved gatsby more than tom, but she does have feelings for tom because she ran his mistress over with a car and it killed her.
- Analyzes how leonardo dicaprio's character of gatsby was focused on emotions, while robert redford and dicaprios had their own way of approaching the character, which made the movie more entertaining.
- Analyzes how nick was more real in the movie. he didn't hold back and gave the audience a reaction that anyone in life would have had if they were in his situation.
- Analyzes how edgerton played an amazing roll in the scene of myrtle's death. elizabeth debicki played daisy' s golfer best friend, jordan baker, but she was not given as many lines as chiles.
- Analyzes how jason clarke played a less wimpy version of george wilson, who was abusive towards myrtle. scott wilson looked pitiful and incapable of murder.
Related Topics
- F. Scott Fitzgerald
24/7 writing help on your phone
To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
The Great Gatsby: Book and Film
Save to my list
Remove from my list
The two texts, ‘The Great Gatsby’, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald in 1926 and its film adaption, ‘The Great Gatsby’, directed by Jack Clayton in 1974 both achieve successful in depicting ‘the decline of the American Dream’ in post war American Society. Confusing a healthier and more fulfilling lifestyle with increased wealth and status is an underlying theme in both texts.
Both texts are seen through the ‘eyes’ of Nick Carraway as he follows and observes an irrepressible dreamer, Jay Gatsby. A man who is trying to grasp an ‘object’ (a ‘wealthy girl’ named Daisy) whom he once had as a love interest.
The Scene in the film adaption, where Nick sets up Gatsby and Daisy’s reunion is very important as it could be viewed as the ‘climax of the film’. In the Novel, this scene occurs in Chapter 5. It begins with Gatsby sending a man over to Nick’s cottage to mow the grass and organising the delivery of great amounts of Daisy’s favourite flowers.
“ Thank you so much for accepting my assignment the night before it was due. I look forward to working with you moving forward ”
In the following quote; ‘The flowers were unnecessary… a greenhouse’, Nick raises the issue of the conspicuous excess of flowers that were filling his Cottage. This scene highlights Gatsby’s obsession to make everything perfect for Daisy’s arrival. This scene in the film adaption however, uses the technique, Mise en Scene in its visual portrayal of the excessive number of flowers in a confined space.
Gatsby frantic rearrangement of Nick’s house to how he likes it; or more so, to how he believes it be appropriate for Daisy’s taste is the climax and is depicted in the novel by, ‘‘of course, of course! They’re fine!’ and he added hollowly, ‘… old sport,’’ (Gatsby dialogue).
By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy . We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email
You won’t be charged yet!
The use of repetition of ‘Of course’, the exclamation mark after ‘They’re Fine!’ and the pause ‘…’ cutting the dialogue illustrates Gatsby’s high emotion, or put simply; a state of panic.
The difference between the two texts is that the film adds the detail of Gatsby hiring men to deliver expensive food, silver cutlery, and tea sets to Nick’s cottage. The adding of the ‘silver’ symbolised wealth and emphasized Gatsby’s fashionable status. It was through this delivery scene in the film that Gatsby was able to show Daisy his wealth. Gatsby’ wanted to please Daisy in any way possible. By making her feel as though she was in ‘her paradise’ he was attempting to win her over Tom Buchanan.
The reunion of Gatsby and Daisy in the film adaption occurs when Daisy is admiring the flowers, and then suddenly looks into the mirror only to realise that Gatsby is standing in her presence. This is very important as it symbolises the ‘intimacy’ the two characters once shared years earlier. The subtle use of the music from non – diegetic, where the intimate music is played, to sound diegetic; where the two characters are talking ‘softly’ to each other creates the effect of intimate tension between Gatsby and Daisy.
In contrast, the novel’s treatment of the reunion of the two characters begins with Gatsby knocking at the door and Nick answering. ‘ then from the living room I heard a sort of choking murmur and part of a laugh…’ This quote supports the idea that there is a theme of mystery. In the film adaption, Nick witnesses Daisy and Gatsby making contact. In the novel however, Nick is not in the room, but close-by outside the room where he can only hear Gatsby and Daisy.
Another technique used in the film adaption was the different portrait/reverse shots of Gatsby and Daisy switching from one to the other, continuously intercutting and slowly zooming on each of their faces. The effect of this technique allows the viewer to be able to gain insight to the emotional state of Gatsby and of Daisy. This technique also helps to convey the tension of this moment, as they had not made contact with each other in 8 years. The novel states that it was coming up to 5 years, ‘five years next November’.
In the film adaption, when the two ‘lovers’ gasp at each other, Nick is awkwardly placed in the middle of the two. Nick is dressed in a ‘boring brown’ colour, which makes him blend into the background. Nick has been used to set up the reunion scene. When Gatsby and Daisy reunite they completely ignore Nick’s presence. ‘A pause; it endured horribly. I had nothing to do in the hall, so I went into the room.’ This quote from the novel depicts how Nick felt when he realised his purpose for Gatsby has been fulfilled. He felt useless.
Dim light was used throughout this scene to send the message to the viewer that it was an intimate secret moment between Gatsby and Daisy. The Camera distance is fairly close to the characters and the shifting of the camera helps depict the perspective and thoughts of each character.
In conclusion by analysing this particular scene, both texts; the novel, ‘The Great Gatsby’ (1926) and the film adaption, ‘The Great Gatsby’ (1974) successfully look at the ‘Decline of the American dream’ through wealth and status. The two texts also depict that this scene through the use of dim light and close camera distance depicts the tension and intimacy of ‘Gatsby and Daisy’s Reunion’. Also the technique of the shifting of the camera helps represent the perspective and thoughts of each character. Therefore even with the added details, the film adaption successfully still follows the sequence of events shown in the novel.
The Great Gatsby: Book and Film. (2020, Jun 02). Retrieved from http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay
"The Great Gatsby: Book and Film." StudyMoose , 2 Jun 2020, http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay
StudyMoose. (2020). The Great Gatsby: Book and Film . [Online]. Available at: http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay [Accessed: 7 Mar. 2023]
"The Great Gatsby: Book and Film." StudyMoose, Jun 02, 2020. Accessed March 7, 2023. http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay
"The Great Gatsby: Book and Film," StudyMoose , 02-Jun-2020. [Online]. Available: http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay. [Accessed: 7-Mar-2023]
StudyMoose. (2020). The Great Gatsby: Book and Film . [Online]. Available at: http://studymoose.com/the-great-gatsby-book-and-film-essay [Accessed: 7-Mar-2023]
- Jay Gatsby's Life in "The Great Gatsby" Pages: 4 (982 words)
- The Great Gatsby: How far can Gatsby be viewed as a tragic hero? Pages: 4 (934 words)
- An Analysis of the Lost Hero of Jay Gatsby in the Novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald Pages: 2 (368 words)
- The Great Gatsby: Film and Novel Comparison Pages: 5 (1489 words)
- Great Gatsby Novel vs Film Pages: 4 (976 words)
- The Great Gatsby and Great Expectations: A Comparison Pages: 4 (968 words)
- The Great Gatsby - Really Great Pages: 2 (485 words)
- The Great Gatsby--Comparison Between 1974 Movie and the Book Pages: 3 (792 words)
- Color Symbolism in Movie and Book the Great Gatsby Pages: 2 (529 words)
- The Great Gatsby Book Vs. Movie Pages: 4 (904 words)
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie?
There are several ways in which the movie by Baz Luhrmann differs from the classic novel. The story portrayed in the film departs from the original text in different scenes. For instance, they are at the very beginning and during the apartment party. Nevertheless, the movie production team did a great job of depicting the classic story.
Detailed answer:
A detailed breakdown of the main differences between the book and the movie includes a few parts. The idea that The Great Gatsby is entirely written by the narrator is not accurate for the movie. Fitzgerald makes it apparent that Nick is telling a story about Gatsby. But this fact is not that obvious for the film viewer. However, Luhrmann still portrays Nick, who is writing, typing, and organizing the manuscript.
Even though the film follows the novel’s plot, the screenwriters end up cutting out some side stories. For example, the affair between Nick and Jordan Barker does not appear in the film. The readers learn that these two become a couple and break up later. But the movie viewers are not exposed to this part of the story at all.
Then, the book does not depict the murder of Jay Gatsby in detail. So the movie director decided to add some drama and describe it precisely. The movie portrays Gatsby dying with the thought that Daisy plans to leave Tom in order to be with him. However, this does not happen in the book.
Looking for an inspiring idea for a paper on The Great Gatsby? Take a look at our Essay Titles for The Great Gatsby: Best Topics and Examples to find the perfect one!
- Short Summary
- Summary (Chapter 1)
- Summary (Chapter 2)
- Summary (Chapter 3)
- Summary (Chapter 4)
- Summary (Chapter 5)
- Summary (Chapter 6)
- Summary (Chapter 7)
- Summary (Chapter 8)
- Summary (Chapter 9)
- Symbolism & Style
- Quotes Explained
- Essay Topics
- Essay Samples
- Questions & Answers
- F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Biography
- Chicago (N-B)
- Chicago (A-D)
IvyPanda. (2022, September 6). What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie? https://ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/
IvyPanda. (2022, September 6). What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie? Retrieved from https://ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/
"What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie?" IvyPanda , 6 Sept. 2022, ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/.
1. IvyPanda . "What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie?" September 6, 2022. https://ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/.
Bibliography
IvyPanda . "What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie?" September 6, 2022. https://ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/.
IvyPanda . 2022. "What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie?" September 6, 2022. https://ivypanda.com/q/what-are-the-main-differences-between-the-great-gatsby-book-and-movie/.
IvyPanda . (2022) 'What Are the Main Differences Between The Great Gatsby Book and Movie'. 6 September.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
The main similarity between the book and the movie “The Outsiders” is that both follow the same storyline. The movie characters have similar roles to the book characters, and Ponyboy serves as the narrator in both pieces.
Gary Paulsen’s book “Hatchet,” the recipient of the 1988 Newbery Award, was adapted into the movie “A Cry in the Wild” in 1990. With a running time of 82 minutes, the film is available for purchase in DVD form via Amazon.
A “who am I” essay is a simple type of open-ended introductory essay. It is used in certain schools, workplaces and around the world to help members of a group introduce themselves through their writing. They are generally about a page long...
Although, both the book and the film effectively portrayed the energy of the 1920s, the characters in the book and the film were not so well-aligned. In
The movie followed the plot of book very closely and portrayed the setting of the book very well. A lot of the dialogue was borrowed and spoken directly as it
The book and movie emphasize the hollowness of the American dream and social class differences (Egan, 2014). Gatsby's mansion emphasizes the class differences
In the book, the theme of wealth is shown consistently through its portrayal and vast differences in status. However, what differs from the book to the film is
One of the most obvious differences is that the book is told from the perspective of Nick Carraway, while the movie focuses on Gatsby himself.
During Gatsby and Daisy's reunion, they claim they have met for 8 years. In the novel, they had
The difference between the ways the book expresses and shows the characters then in the movie, but the movie helps you understand the plot and storyline better.
The differences and similarities are definitely noticeable. The setting of the novel is different from the film. Tom is just one of the five characters that
In this essay, the author. Opines that the book, the great gatsby by f. scott fitzgerald, is superior to the movie adaptation because many scenes were altered
The difference between the two texts is that the film adds the detail of
The idea that The Great Gatsby is entirely written by the narrator is not accurate for the movie. Fitzgerald makes it apparent that Nick is